Jami Mullikin • August 12, 2024

Paid Search vs SEO – Apples Today or an Orchard Tomorrow?

Sometimes qualifying your prospects who are interested in paid search or SEO services can be heard. To make it more relatable, let's use an analogy: think of paid search as buying apples and organic search, or SEO, as planting an apple orchard.


If a clients need results today, they may be best served with paid search - or buying apples today at retail prices. If they're looking further out, and desire a longer-term competitive advantage and can postpone the immediate ROI, then organic search, or search engine optimization, may be a better bet - it's more like growing apples. 


Should we recommend Paid Search or SEO?


Buying Apples Today: Paid Search


When a prospect or client expresses interest in paid search, it's like they need apples today. They want immediate results, and they're willing to pay for it. Here are the key reasons why this might be the best option for them:


  • Instant Visibility: Just like finding apples in the store, paid search gives businesses immediate visibility on search engine result pages.


  • Targeted Traffic: With paid search, businesses can target their ads towards a specific audience based on factors like location, demographics, and even the time of day.


  • Control Over Budget and Bidding: Paid search allows businesses to control how much they spend. They can set a budget cap to ensure they don't overspend and can adjust their bidding strategy based on the performance of their ads.


  • Tracking and Measurability: Paid search campaigns are highly measurable. Businesses can track the number of clicks, conversions, and the return on investment (ROI) with precision.


  • Boost Short-Term Sales: If a business has a seasonal product or a time-sensitive offer, paid search is an excellent way to drive short-term sales.


  • Increased Brand Awareness: Although the short-term ROI can measured quickly, paid search also provide potentially millions of brand impressions that in essence has no cost at all.


Planting an Apple Tree for Tomorrow: Search Engine Optimization


On the other hand, when a prospect is interested in their Google rankings, they're thinking long-term. They want to plant an apple tree today, knowing it will yield a steady supply of apples in the future. Here are some reasons why SEO could be their best bet:


  • Sustainable Visibility: Once a website ranks high in organic search results, it tends to stay there for a while. This leads to sustained visibility without the ongoing cost of paid media or paid search campaigns.


  • Builds Trust and Credibility: Users tend to trust organic search results more than paid ads. Ranking high in organic search signals to users that your site is a credible source of information.


  • Cost-Effective in the Long Run: While SEO requires an upfront investment, it’s often more cost-effective over the long haul. Unlike paid search, organic traffic from search rankings are free, so your cost per acquisition decreases over time.


  • Improved User Experience: A well-optimized website is not just search-engine friendly but user-friendly too. Good SEO practices improve site speed, usability, and mobile-friendliness.


  • Long-Term Growth: SEO, like planting an orchard full of trees, is a long-term investment. It might take some time to see results, but once it starts bearing fruit, it provides a steady flow of organic traffic and leads.


Buying Apples Today and Planting an Orchard for Tomorrow: A Combined Approach


In some cases, your clients might benefit most from a combined approach — buying apples today (paid search) while planting an apple orchard for tomorrow (SEO). This strategy provides the instant results of paid search with the sustainable, long-term benefits of SEO. Here are some reasons why this approach could be their best bet:

 

  • Balancing Short and Long-Term Goals: By using both strategies, businesses can meet their immediate sales targets while also laying the groundwork for future, organic growth.


  • Insights and Data: Running paid campaigns can provide valuable data and insights that can be used to inform and optimize the SEO strategy. You get to know which keywords are performing well, what language resonates with your audience, and which demographics are more likely to convert.


  • Visibility Boost: Combining SEO with paid search can enhance a brand's visibility on the search engine results page, increasing the likelihood of click-throughs. Your brand appears both in the paid ad section and in the organic results, which can boost your credibility and reach.


  • Mitigate SEO Volatility: Search engine algorithms change frequently, which can impact your organic rankings. Paid search ads can help to maintain your visibility and traffic during these periods of SEO volatility.


  • Holistic Strategy: A combined approach ensures you have a more holistic digital marketing strategy. You’re not putting all your eggs in one basket, but leveraging the strengths of both paid search and SEO.


So, How About Those Apples?

In the world of digital marketing, understanding whether your prospects are looking to 'buy apples today' or 'plant an orchard for tomorrow' is crucial to guiding them to the right solution. Both paid search and SEO have their strengths and are suitable for different situations. It's all about identifying the needs of your prospects and aligning them with the right approach to meet their objectives. As an agency partner, your job is to help them understand which option is best for their unique situation and make sound recommendations to help them reach their goals.


Share this post

Recent Posts

Wonder's MAP Brief™ EOS Compatible Marketing Operating System
By Jami Mullikin June 23, 2026
More than a decade ago, I was serving as Vice President of Sales and Marketing for a growing company. We were preparing for annual planning, and like most organizations, we had a long list of things we wanted to accomplish. Before the planning process started, I asked the CEO for thirty minutes. I told him I had one question. "If we jump forward a year and this plan absolutely crushed it, how would we know?" Then I waited. What followed changed the way I think about planning. He didn't start talking about marketing. He didn't mention trade shows, campaigns, advertising, websites, or lead generation. Instead, he described what success would look like for the business. Revenue growth. New opportunities. Strategic wins. The kinds of outcomes that would make us all look back and say, "That was a great year." It was a simple conversation, but it revealed something important. Most planning starts with activity when it should start with outcomes. We spend a lot of time talking about what we're going to do before we've fully aligned on what we're trying to accomplish. That idea stayed with me for years. Later, when I discovered EOS, it immediately clicked. The 3-Year Picture, the 1-Year Plan, and quarterly Rocks all start with the same principle. Define the future first. Then work backward to determine what needs to happen next. Over time, that thinking evolved into what we now call the MAP Brief™. The MAP Brief™ is a simple tool we use with every client at Wonder. It helps leadership, sales, and marketing align around a shared vision of success before we ever start talking about campaigns or tactics. The first page captures the big picture. Where are we today? What does success look like three years from now? What needs to happen this year? What are the key strategies that will get us there? The second page translates those strategies into quarterly priorities. This is where strategy becomes activation. Instead of creating a long list of marketing activities, we identify the Rocks that matter most over the next 90 days and build momentum one quarter at a time. Like the EOS V/TO, what I love most about the MAP Brief™ is its simplicity. It's not a hundred-page strategic plan. It's not a complicated marketing framework. It's a conversation tool that helps everyone stay aligned around the same goals. We use it internally. We use it with clients. We revisit it regularly whenever priorities shift or new opportunities emerge. Most importantly, it helps answer a question that every leadership team should be asking: What has to be true for this year to be considered a success? Everything else becomes much easier once that answer is clear. We've made our MAP Brief™ template available as a free download. If you're looking for a simple way to align leadership, sales, and marketing around your annual objectives, I hope you'll give it a try. Download the Free MAP Brief™ Template Use it. Make it your own. We hope it helps your team create the same kind of alignment it has created for ours and for the clients we serve.
By Jami Mullikin June 9, 2026
Greenville, S.C.-based agency becomes an approved strategic partner of EOS Worldwide, giving companies running on EOS access to a marketing partner fully aligned with their operating system
Wonder's MAP Brief™ EOS Compatible Marketing Operating System
By Jami Mullikin June 23, 2026
More than a decade ago, I was serving as Vice President of Sales and Marketing for a growing company. We were preparing for annual planning, and like most organizations, we had a long list of things we wanted to accomplish. Before the planning process started, I asked the CEO for thirty minutes. I told him I had one question. "If we jump forward a year and this plan absolutely crushed it, how would we know?" Then I waited. What followed changed the way I think about planning. He didn't start talking about marketing. He didn't mention trade shows, campaigns, advertising, websites, or lead generation. Instead, he described what success would look like for the business. Revenue growth. New opportunities. Strategic wins. The kinds of outcomes that would make us all look back and say, "That was a great year." It was a simple conversation, but it revealed something important. Most planning starts with activity when it should start with outcomes. We spend a lot of time talking about what we're going to do before we've fully aligned on what we're trying to accomplish. That idea stayed with me for years. Later, when I discovered EOS, it immediately clicked. The 3-Year Picture, the 1-Year Plan, and quarterly Rocks all start with the same principle. Define the future first. Then work backward to determine what needs to happen next. Over time, that thinking evolved into what we now call the MAP Brief™. The MAP Brief™ is a simple tool we use with every client at Wonder. It helps leadership, sales, and marketing align around a shared vision of success before we ever start talking about campaigns or tactics. The first page captures the big picture. Where are we today? What does success look like three years from now? What needs to happen this year? What are the key strategies that will get us there? The second page translates those strategies into quarterly priorities. This is where strategy becomes activation. Instead of creating a long list of marketing activities, we identify the Rocks that matter most over the next 90 days and build momentum one quarter at a time. Like the EOS V/TO, what I love most about the MAP Brief™ is its simplicity. It's not a hundred-page strategic plan. It's not a complicated marketing framework. It's a conversation tool that helps everyone stay aligned around the same goals. We use it internally. We use it with clients. We revisit it regularly whenever priorities shift or new opportunities emerge. Most importantly, it helps answer a question that every leadership team should be asking: What has to be true for this year to be considered a success? Everything else becomes much easier once that answer is clear. We've made our MAP Brief™ template available as a free download. If you're looking for a simple way to align leadership, sales, and marketing around your annual objectives, I hope you'll give it a try. Download the Free MAP Brief™ Template Use it. Make it your own. We hope it helps your team create the same kind of alignment it has created for ours and for the clients we serve.
By Jami Mullikin June 9, 2026
Greenville, S.C.-based agency becomes an approved strategic partner of EOS Worldwide, giving companies running on EOS access to a marketing partner fully aligned with their operating system